Tag Archive for 'review'Page 2 of 2

Free Comic Book Day 2008 - A Humble Marvel Adventures Confession

Marvel Adventures FCBD 2008A little over one week ago, I came to this forum — known among savvy readers as the awesome AudioShocker — and talked smack on the Marvel Adventures Free Comic Book Day offering from Marvel Comics.

Truth be told, talking smack is a bit of an exaggeration. It was more like expressing disappointment. And I was disappointed at the time — I had read the issue and it just didn’t live up to my standards.

Truth be told, saying I read the issue is a bit of an exaggeration. It was more like I read the first two-thirds of the story, and then I made assumptions about the rest of the issue.

I’m embarrassed to admit it, but I reviewed the issue without finishing it. I broke the unbreakable rule of reviewing — don’t review something that you have read, seen, watched, or listened to from start to finish.

It just so happens that I finished reading the Marvel Adventures FCBD 2008 issue on Saturday, and DAMN! what an ending! Once the Mandarin shows up for a second time, the story really hits a groove and finishes in fine form.

Elephant SteveI apologize for giving an opinion half-cocked. It was wrong. And I’m grateful for finishing this excellent comic book by Jeff Parker, Paul Tobin, Alvin Lee, Terry Pallot, Wil Quintana, and Nate Piekos.

To make matters even better, the issue finished off with a Mini Marvels comic strip by Chris Giarrusso featuring none other than Elephant Steve! I love Elephant Steve. And I love this comic book.

Bizarre New World: Population Explosion comic book review

This graphic novel hits today and I’ve been fortunate to catch an advanced peak at the book. With that said, here’s what I like most about this story: its realistic treatment of a fantastic topic, fun art that’s bright and expressive, and the story’s unique length.

The concept is simple. Paul Krutcher can fly, and he’s the first guy with this ability. But that was in the last Bizarre New World tale. As Population Explosion begins, just about everyone has discovered they can defy gravity as well. The skies are a mess of reckless, elated people. It’s an interesting take on flight by writer Skipper Martin.

And now Paul is disappointed. Not only is he robbed of feeling special — he’s trying to take flying seriously while everyone else is going on joyrides. The conflict is quickly introduced as Paul receives a garbled and hectic phone call from his son. Paul immediately sets off on a haphazard journey to save his child that might not even need to be saved.

The pencils by Christopher Provencher are expressive and attractive. They have an animated quality that plays up the fun of every panel (even when the story itself isn’t dealing with a fun topic). The colors by Wes Dzioba take the strong pencils by Provencher and slather them with bright colors that enhance the overall visual effect of the story.

But it’s the lettering by Ellen Everett that really steals the show. She uses a few great techniques to make the different forms of narration distinct. When you finally see all the different types of text converge, you know that she’s got something special going on.

I was really enthused about the size of this graphic novel from Ape Entertainment. It’s about 50 pages, clocking in at slightly more than two standard comic book issues. According to Diamond Distributors, it carries a price tag of $6.95. I think that’s a fair price concerning the quality and the page count of the tale. I hope more writers think about doing books of this size in the future.

Those are all the best parts. Now here’s what didn’t work for me. While I found the overall concept charming, I didn’t think that Martin really hit his stride until page 20. At that point, he introduced the concept of deadly (yet hilarious) mass hysteria. That was interesting for me. But the main conflict up until that point didn’t completely sell me on the story. To add to that, there was a decidedly folksy tone to the internal narration and external interactions of Paul. By the time I was hit with a preachy moment about 9/11, I felt soaked in Americana reflection. It killed the fantasy buzz of the story for me.

But all complaints aside, this book has a fun and inventive treatment of human flight. It has bright, bouncy art that works hard to maintain the fun tone, and its length is just right. I recommend this book to people excited by extraordinary possibilities but a bit burned out by the extreme science-fiction overdose of modern superhero comics.

5 out of 7 Shocks

ComicShocker Week 14 2008

I guess I expected Secret Invasion #1 to be a bit more shocking. Not that it wasn’t good - Lenil Yu’s pencils look strong with Mark Morales on inks and Laura Martin on colors; Brian Michael Bendis delivers a strong script. But the overall story felt much like your typical issue of New Avengers. That’s a good thing, of course. But not necessarily an event comic thing.

I certainly wasn’t out and out taken aback by any Skrull development that happened. Surprised a bit? Maybe here and there. But no “knock me on my ass” moments like the first issue of Civil War. I remember finishing Civil War #1 with my mouth agape, shocked at the words of Iron Man. It had attitude like the Bad Boys movies and hyper-real visuals. Secret Invasion, on the other hand, has a decidedly slow burn pace that feels more like a political thriller than a big action movie.

And I’m sure that’s the point. I imagine that Bendis wants this story to read a bit more mature and subtle than the past two Marvel Comics spring / summer events (the aforementioned Civil War and World War Hulk). To that end, he is successful. However, I didn’t drop my jaw anywhere. I didn’t even scream anything out loud, often a sign that I’m lost in the fictional illusion of the story to my delight.

But like I said, the book is good. I’m not going to be spoilerish, that is unless talking about the fulfillment of expectations counts as spoilers (which, this reader believes, can have way more spoiler potential than learning about the plot). It is excellent to see Luke Cage as a pivotal player in the Marvel Universe, even if Lenil Yu doesn’t know which way his tiara should be facing (ooo, watch out for spoilers!!!).

My favorite part of the issue? Three words: Reed Richards spaghetti. Mr. Fantastic needs to score a licensing deal with Ragu now. Visually, this moment is a close second only to Clor getting his robotic brains bashed out by Hercules. It’s creepy and fascinating at the same time.

Comic Pick - Week 41 2007

Fantastic Four #550Fantastic Four #550 is the best of McDuffie’s tales yet on this run. It’s smart, bold, big, and human. It takes the team from the furthest reaches of space and reality back to their kitchen. It’s pure sci-fi superhero fun. It’s also thoughtful and very compassionate, which really sold me.

*Sniffle* The main reason I was picking up this series will soon be gone. This is the final issue featuring Black Panther and Storm as regular cast members, and DAMN what a story. The other reason I was picking up this book - Dwanye McDuffie - will also be departing, but he has at least two issues to go. His brilliant storytelling has taken a series that I always struggled to enjoy and turned it into one of my favorite must-read comic books.

If you want to get some more in-depth info on this issue, check out my full review of Fantastic Four #550.